Skip to main content

Gusto review: the base fee is what makes it expensive for small teams

Gusto charges a monthly base plus a per-employee rate. Simple is $49 plus $6 each, which works out near $16 a head at five employees and about $7 at fifty.

By Tashawar AwaisResearcher and editor
Last updated 3 min readPricing verified

Verdict

Editor's note

Gusto charges a base fee plus per employee. Simple is $49 base plus $6 each. At five employees that is about $16 per head; at fifty it is about $7. The base fee punishes small teams.

Gusto at a glance

Starting price
$49/mo base plus $6/employee
Free plan
No
Prices checked
August 30, 2026
Visit Gusto(opens in a new tab)

Pros and cons

What works

  • Published pricing with no quote required, which is rare in payroll and HR software
  • Payroll tax filing is included rather than an add-on, which is the whole reason to buy payroll software
  • The Contractor Only plan removes the base fee problem entirely if you have no employees
  • Effective cost per head falls steeply as headcount grows, so it gets better rather than worse

What does not

  • The base fee means a five-person company pays roughly $16 an employee against about $7 at fifty
  • Simple rose from $40 to $49 in March 2026, so older quoted figures understate it
  • Multi-state payroll requires Plus at $80 base plus $12 each, a real jump
  • Premium at $180 base is priced for companies that want an HR advisor, not payroll

The pricing shape matters more than the price#

$16 against $7

Effective cost per employee on Simple, at 5 people and at 50

Same plan. The base fee is fixed, so it dominates when headcount is low.

Gusto charges a base fee plus a per-employee rate. That structure decides whether it is cheap or expensive for you, and it has nothing to do with features.

EmployeesSimple, monthlyPer head
3$67About $22
5$79About $16
15$139About $9
50$349About $7

So the same product costs three times as much per person at three employees as at fifty.

The plans#

PlanBasePer employeeWhy you would
Simple$49$6Single-state payroll, tax filing
Plus$80$12Multi-state, time tracking, onboarding
Premium$180$22HR advisory and a success manager

Simple rose from $40 to $49 in March 2026. Older comparisons still quote $40.

What you are actually buying#

Payroll tax filing. That is the product. Calculating withholding, filing with the right agencies, and being responsible when it goes wrong.

Everything else is a reason to move up a tier. If payroll tax filing is not the problem you have, you probably do not need payroll software.

Where the tier jump is forced#

Multi-state. One employee in another state moves you from Simple to Plus. That is $49 plus $6 each becoming $80 plus $12 each.

At ten employees that is $109 becoming $200. Nearly double, for a compliance requirement rather than a feature you wanted.

Worth knowing before you hire remotely.

The contractor case#

If you have no employees, only contractors, Contractor Only is the right product. Currently a promotional $0 base, normally $35, plus $6 per contractor.

Buying Simple to pay contractors means paying a $49 base for payroll functionality you are not using. It is a common and avoidable mistake.

The verdict#

Worth it if you have roughly ten or more employees and want payroll tax filing to stop being your problem. At that headcount the effective cost per head is reasonable and the product is good.

Not worth it if you have two or three employees. The base fee makes it expensive per head, and at that size the honest question is whether you need payroll software at all or whether your accountant already handles it.

If your requirement is HR rather than payroll, BambooHR is aimed at that instead, with its own pricing floor problem at small headcount.

Gusto pricing

Gusto plans, prices, and what each plan includes
PlanPriceWhat you getBest for
Contractor Only$0 promotional base, normally $35plus $6 per contractor / monthContractor payments and 1099 filingA business with contractors and no employees
Simple$49 baseplus $6 per employee / monthSingle-state payroll, tax filing, basic benefits administrationA single-state company that needs payroll run correctly
Plus$80 baseplus $12 per employee / monthMulti-state payroll, next-day deposit, time tracking, onboardingCompanies with staff in more than one state
Premium$180 baseplus $22 per employee / monthDedicated success manager, HR advisory, compliance alerts, performance reviewsCompanies that want HR support rather than only payroll

Prices in US dollars, checked on August 30, 2026. Vendors change pricing without notice.

Who Gusto is for

Buy it if

  • You have ten or more employees, where the base fee stops dominating the bill
  • You want payroll tax filing handled rather than being your problem
  • You value published pricing over a quote process

Skip it if

  • You have two or three employees, where the base fee is most of what you pay
  • You only pay contractors, in which case the Contractor Only plan is the right product, not Simple
  • You need deep HR tooling, which arrives at Premium and costs accordingly

Frequently asked questions

How much does Gusto cost?
Simple is $49 a month base plus $6 per employee, Plus is $80 base plus $12, and Premium is $180 base plus $22. There is also a Contractor Only plan at a promotional $0 base, normally $35, plus $6 per contractor.
Why does Gusto seem expensive for a small team?
The base fee. At five employees on Simple you pay $49 plus $30, which is $79 a month or about $16 a head. At fifty employees the same plan is $349, or about $7 a head. The base fee is fixed, so it dominates the bill when headcount is low.
Did Gusto put its prices up?
Yes. The Simple plan rose from $40 to $49 a month in March 2026. Any figure quoted before that understates the current cost, which matters because a lot of published comparisons have not been updated.
Do I need Plus or is Simple enough?
Simple covers single-state payroll and tax filing, which is the whole job for most small companies. Plus exists mainly for multi-state payroll, and if you have one employee in another state you have no choice. Time tracking and onboarding are the secondary reasons.
Portrait of Tashawar Awais

Written by

Tashawar Awais

Researcher and editor

Tashawar handles verification and editing. Every figure in a review is checked a second time before it goes out, and anything that cannot be traced to a vendor page or a documented source is either qualified or cut. Where pricing is genuinely unclear, as it is with Canva team plans or Close CRM tiers, the article says so and tells the reader to confirm directly instead of quoting a number with false confidence.

  • Second check on every published figure
  • Removes claims the sources do not support
  • Flags pricing that changes without notice