Skip to main content

Gusto vs BambooHR: payroll with HR against HR with payroll

Gusto is $49 base plus $6 an employee. BambooHR quotes about $10 a head but charges a flat $250 floor under 25 staff. Both are worst value at exactly the size most buyers are.

By Tashawar AwaisResearcher and editor
Last updated 3 min readPricing verified

Verdict

Head to head

Gusto is payroll with HR attached and BambooHR is HR with payroll available. Gusto charges $49 base plus $6 each. BambooHR charges a flat rate near $250 below 25 employees.

At a glance

Side-by-side comparison of Gusto, BambooHR
CriterionGustoBest for payrollBambooHRBest for HR
What it is built aroundPayrollHR records
Pricing modelBase fee plus per employeePer employee, flat floor under 25
Published pricingYesNo, quoted
Cost at 10 employeesAbout $109/mo on SimpleAbout $250/mo flat
Payroll tax filingIncludedMarket dependent
Onboarding workflowsPlus tierCore
Performance reviewsPremium tierPro
Full reviewRead the Gusto reviewRead the BambooHR review

What the winner gets right, and where it falls short

What works

  • Gusto publishes its prices, so you can budget without a sales conversation
  • BambooHR employee self-service removes more admin work than any payroll tool does
  • Both are genuinely good at their own job rather than mediocre at both

What does not

  • Both are worst value at ten to fifteen employees, which is where most buyers sit
  • BambooHR flat rate below 25 staff means a ten-person company pays about $25 a head
  • Running both, which is common, means two bills for overlapping employee records

They solve different problems#

Payroll or people

The question that decides this

Both are sold as people software. Only one of them files your payroll taxes.

Gusto is payroll software with HR features attached. The product is calculating withholding, filing with the right agencies, and being responsible when it goes wrong.

BambooHR is HR software with payroll available in some markets. The product is employee records, onboarding, time off, and performance.

Choosing between them means deciding which of those is actually costing you hours. That is usually obvious once you ask it directly.

The pricing shapes are both awkward at the same size#

This is the honest finding, and it applies to both.

EmployeesGusto SimpleBambooHR
5About $79/moAbout $250/mo flat
10About $109/moAbout $250/mo flat
25About $199/moAbout $250/mo flat
50About $349/moPer head, around $500 on Core

Gusto is still much cheaper there. But it is worth knowing that neither is priced for you yet, because it changes how much software you should be buying at all.

What each is genuinely better at#

Gusto: payroll tax filing, published pricing, and the Contractor Only plan if you have no employees at all. It gets steadily cheaper per head as you grow.

BambooHR: employee self-service, which is the feature that actually reduces HR hours because people find their own documents and book their own time off. Also reporting on headcount and turnover, which payroll tools do badly.

Where the tier jumps hurt#

Gusto: multi-state payroll forces you from Simple to Plus. That is $49 plus $6 each becoming $80 plus $12 each. At ten employees, $109 becomes $200. One remote hire in another state does it.

BambooHR: performance management sits on Pro at about $17 rather than Core at about $10. Nearly double per head for one capability.

The both-tools trap#

Plenty of companies run Gusto for payroll and BambooHR for HR.

That works, and it means two systems holding overlapping employee records and two bills. Before committing to it, check two things: whether Gusto Plus or Premium covers enough HR for you, and whether BambooHR includes payroll in your market.

Paying twice for overlapping products is common and frequently avoidable.

Choosing in one line#

Payroll is the problem → Gusto. Start on Simple unless you have staff in more than one state.

Onboarding, records, and time off are the problem → BambooHR, but only if you are near or past 25 employees. Below that the flat rate is hard to justify.

Under ten employees and unsure → Gusto Simple, and revisit HR software when the headcount makes it worth it. At that size a shared drive and a calendar genuinely do compete.

No employees, only contractors → Gusto Contractor Only, not either full product.

If budget is the constraint rather than the choice, the free and low-cost end of this market is covered in free payroll software.

Tool by tool

Gusto

Best for payroll

Payroll tax filing is the product, and it is included rather than an add-on. Published pricing means you can budget without a sales call.

Starting price
$49/mo base plus $6/employee
Best for
Companies whose actual problem is running payroll correctly

BambooHR

Best for HR

Built around HR records, onboarding, and self-service rather than payroll. Reporting on headcount and turnover is better than any payroll tool produces.

Starting price
About $10/employee, flat rate under 25 staff
Best for
Companies where onboarding, records, and time off eat real hours

Frequently asked questions

Should I choose Gusto or BambooHR?
Ask what is actually costing you time. If it is running payroll and filing payroll taxes, Gusto. If it is onboarding, employee records, time off requests, and performance cycles, BambooHR. They are not competing for the same job despite both being sold as people software.
Which is cheaper for a small company?
Gusto, clearly, below 25 employees. A ten-person company pays about $109 a month on Gusto Simple against a BambooHR flat rate starting near $250. Above 25 staff the comparison narrows because BambooHR switches to per-employee pricing.
Do I need both?
Some companies run both, which is two bills for overlapping employee records. Before doing that, check whether Gusto Plus or Premium covers enough HR for you, or whether your BambooHR market includes payroll. Paying twice is common and often avoidable.
Does BambooHR do payroll?
In some markets, yes, but the platform is not built around payroll processing the way Gusto is. If payroll correctness is your main concern, treat BambooHR payroll as a secondary consideration rather than the reason to buy.
Portrait of Tashawar Awais

Written by

Tashawar Awais

Researcher and editor

Tashawar handles verification and editing. Every figure in a review is checked a second time before it goes out, and anything that cannot be traced to a vendor page or a documented source is either qualified or cut. Where pricing is genuinely unclear, as it is with Canva team plans or Close CRM tiers, the article says so and tells the reader to confirm directly instead of quoting a number with false confidence.

  • Second check on every published figure
  • Removes claims the sources do not support
  • Flags pricing that changes without notice